Room 4 Review

This blog is an opportunity for my students (Morrinsville Intermediate, Waikato, New Zealand), to share books, movies, music and other interests through reviews and comments.

Monday, August 31, 2009

The Return of the Killer Cat, by Anne Fine-A review by Caralena


The return of the killer cat is a great story about a cat called “Tuffy” and a cat sitter. When Tuffy’s family goes away for the week the cat sitter comes to stay.
There is a war between them both and I wonder who wins? My favourite part of the story is when Tuffy falls out of the tree and gets dressed up as a baby boy by Melanie the annoying neighbour.
Anne Fine is the author of this book she is a great children’s author. She has written other stories like “the diary of a killer cat “and “not so hot so” and many, many more.
I reckon this book was a funny and awesome book because of the war between the cat and the cat sitter. The book was easy so I think I would have been better for year 4-5-6.

Holes by Louis Sachar-Review by Amber


Holes, by Louis Sachar, is a book about Stanley Yelnats, an unfortunate boy who is sent to a juvenile detention centre for a crime he didn’t commit. Each day Stanley and the other boys at Camp Green Lake must each dig a hole 5 feet by 5 feet in the hot desert surrounding the camp. This is supposed to “improve on their bad attitude”. But what are they digging for? Stanley and his new best friend Zero are determined to find out. Join them in this book which goes between past and present events at Green Lake Texas, with all the threads of the story coming together in the end.
If you enjoy creative and exiting books, I would recommend Holes as Louis Sacher’s style of writing is really easy to understand even as it flicks backwards and forwards between times. His style is really creative as it slowly pieces key events together.
If you have enjoyed reading this book I would recommend the movie of Holes, which is just as exciting as the book.
I would say that the theme of this book is friendship between Stanley and Zero. Stories of Stanley’s great great grandfather’s past and the excitement of what goes on in the camp and what Stanley finds out about his past, contribute to the idea that good people get their reward in the end and bad people get punished.
I definitely would recommend this book as I found it really exiting to read. I would give this book to Adults and kids 9+ to read.
By Amber.S